“Controversial California Bill: Should Tackle Football for Kids Under 12 Be Banned?”

9

California Lawmakers to Debate Ban on Tackle Football for Kids Under 12

California lawmakers will gather on Wednesday to discuss a controversial bill that seeks to ban tackle football for children under the age of 12. The proposed legislation, authored by Democratic Assemblymember Kevin McCarty, aims to protect kids from brain damage associated with the sport. However, it faces opposition from coaches who argue that it would deprive youths of an important physical activity.

Crucial Hearing for the Bill

The bill is scheduled for its first public hearing before a legislative committee. While it still has a long way to go before becoming law, this hearing is crucial. To have a chance of passing this year, the bill must clear the state Assembly by the end of January.

If approved, the ban would not take effect until 2026. Proposed amendments suggest a gradual implementation through 2029. The timing of the bill coincides with the increasing popularity of flag football, particularly among girls.

The New Britain Jr. Hurricanes Heads Up Football practice on October 9, 2013 in New Britain, Connecticut.
The New Britain Jr. Hurricanes Heads Up Football practice on October 9, 2013 in New Britain, Connecticut. (Kike Calvo / AP Images for National Football League)

The Impact of Tackle Football on Brain Health

Research has indicated that tackle football can cause brain damage, with the risk increasing over time. According to Chris Nowinski, CEO of the Concussion Legacy Foundation and a former Harvard football player and WWE professional wrestler, it can lead to chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), which results in the death of nerve cells in the brain.

While Nowinski acknowledges that NFL players understand the risks and are compensated, he emphasizes the importance of protecting children who may not fully comprehend the potential dangers. He questions the idea of children willingly subjecting themselves to such risks for the sake of fun.

Previous Attempts to Ban Tackle Football

Although no state has yet banned tackle football for kids, similar bills have been introduced in California, New York, and Illinois in the past. However, these attempts failed to pass.

Concerns About Youth Football Players

Opponents of the ban argue that tackle football provides opportunities for certain types of players who may not excel in other sports. For example, heavier or less physically developed kids often find a place on youth football teams, where they can play as offensive and defensive linemen. Critics worry that banning tackle football would leave these kids without a suitable alternative.

Declining High School Football Participation

In California, tackle football participation at the high school level has been declining. From 2015 to 2022, there was an 18% drop from a peak of 103,725 players to 84,626 players, according to the California Interscholastic Federation’s participation survey. However, there was a 5% increase in participation in 2023, with the number of players rising to 89,178.

The Future of Tackle Football for Kids

The debate surrounding the ban on tackle football for children under 12 is ongoing. While advocates emphasize the need to protect young athletes from brain damage, opponents raise concerns about the potential consequences for youth physical activity and certain types of players. As the bill progresses through the legislative process, its fate remains uncertain.