SEC Suspends Biden’s Controversial Climate Disclosure Rule Amid Legal Storm


Original Source: LA News Center

A Temporary Suspension

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has temporarily suspended its contentious rule requiring private companies to disclose carbon emissions data, a move prompted by a slew of lawsuits challenging the mandate.

The Lawsuits and Legal Challenges

The rule, approved in March, immediately faced legal challenges from a coalition of 25 Republican Attorneys General, as well as energy companies and business groups. They argued that the rule exceeded the SEC’s authority and would impose excessive financial burdens on businesses.

In April, the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals granted a brief administrative stay of the rule while several lawsuits were consolidated. The groups involved requested the 8th Circuit Court to compel the SEC to block the rule on a permanent basis.

On Friday, the SEC voluntarily agreed to temporarily suspend the rule while the legal battle continues. This was seen as a strategic move, as the SEC’s legal team assessed the strength of their arguments and potential risks of enforcing the rule amidst the ongoing litigation.

Political Reactions

Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey expressed his satisfaction with the suspension, calling it a “huge win.” He argued that the rule was part of President Biden’s “radical green scheme” and would have imposed millions of dollars in costs on Missouri businesses annually.

SEC’s Defense and Future of the Rule

In a letter to the 8th Circuit Court, the SEC reaffirmed its belief that the rule complies with applicable law and falls within the Commission’s authority. However, they acknowledged that a stay would avoid potential regulatory uncertainty and facilitate the orderly resolution of the legal challenges.

The future of the climate disclosure rule remains uncertain. The ongoing litigation and potential court rulings will likely determine the ultimate fate of this contentious regulation.

Background: The Disclosure Rule and Its Intent

Under Chairman Gary Gensler, appointed by President Biden, the SEC approved the climate disclosure rules on March 6 in a 3-2 vote. The SEC has defended its decision, stating that the rules align with investors’ demand for consistent and reliable information about climate-related financial risks.

The rules aimed to standardize how companies report carbon emissions, climate risk exposure, and plans to transition to a lower-carbon economy.

Reservations and Controversies

Opponents of the rule argued that it would impose significant costs and burdens on businesses without providing meaningful benefits. They also questioned the SEC’s authority to regulate climate-related disclosures, arguing that it overreached beyond its traditional role.

The SEC maintained that the rule was essential to providing investors with the information they needed to make informed decisions. The debate highlighted the increasing politicization of climate policy and the tension between environmental concerns and economic interests.

The temporary suspension of the rule provides a respite while the legal challenges are resolved. The outcome of these lawsuits and the future path of the climate disclosure rule will be closely watched by businesses, investors, and environmental advocates alike.

Data sourced from: