Stephen A. Smith and Monica McNutt Clash Over WNBA and Race


Clash of Opinions on “First Take”: ESPN’s Smith and McNutt Engage in Heated WNBA Debate

Los Angeles News Center

The Women’s National Basketball Association (WNBA) took center stage in Monday’s “First Take” on LA News Center, igniting a lively debate between Stephen A. Smith and Monica McNutt. The topic centered around a controversial incident involving Caitlin Clark and Chennedy Carter, and the ensuing fallout in both the media and the fan base.

McNutt’s Concerns: Unfair Treatment and Unwarranted Attention

McNutt opened the discussion by expressing concern that new WNBA fans might interpret the recent media coverage as biased against Clark. She argued that the overwhelming focus on Clark’s arrival and her immediate impact has overshadowed the efforts and contributions of established WNBA players who have paved the way for her success.

“There’s a sentiment that the WNBA is targeting Caitlin Clark because she’s a rookie and bringing in new fans,” McNutt stated. “But these women have worked tirelessly to build the league, and they deserve recognition for that.”

Smith’s Defense: More Attention, Not Unfair Treatment

Smith, however, countered McNutt’s claims by highlighting the increased attention and exposure that “First Take” and other sports platforms have given to the WNBA. He argued that such coverage has only benefited the league and its players, including Clark.

“We give the WNBA the attention it deserves,” Smith asserted. “And we talk about the league in the same way we discuss men’s sports. We critique, we analyze, and we provide our opinions.”

Jealousy and Privilege: Smith’s Controversial Allegations

The debate took a turn when Smith suggested that some WNBA players might be harboring jealousy towards Clark due to her race and star power. He claimed that the resentment stems from Clark’s swift rise to fame and her perceived privilege as a white player in a league with predominantly Black athletes.

“There are girls in the WNBA who are jealous of Caitlin Clark,” Smith said. “She’s a white girl who’s come into the league and taken the spotlight, leaving them in her shadow.”

McNutt’s Rebuttal: Navigating the Challenges of Being a Woman

McNutt fiercely disagreed with Smith’s assertion, stating that the challenges women face in sports are not solely determined by race. She pointed out that women in general must navigate a different set of expectations and biases in the media and the public discourse.

“Welcome to the world of being a woman, Stephen A.,” McNutt retorted. “You have to carefully consider your every word and action because you’re constantly being judged and scrutinized.”

Cutting Through the Noise: Recognizing Merit and Competition

As the debate reached its peak, LA News Center host Molly Qerim interceded, calling for an end to the personal attacks and a focus on analyzing Clark’s performance on the court.

“Let’s shift the conversation away from jealousy and privilege,” Qerim said. “We need to acknowledge Clark’s talent and her contributions to the Fever, while also respecting the efforts of all WNBA players.”

Impact on the WNBA: Acknowledging Growth and Criticism

Ultimately, the heated exchange between Smith and McNutt reflects the diverse perspectives and complexities surrounding the WNBA. While there is undeniable progress in terms of media coverage and fan engagement, the league and its players continue to face challenges and criticisms.

Clark’s presence has undoubtedly brought new attention to the WNBA, but it has also sparked conversations about the future of the league and the recognition of players who have long toiled in its ranks. The ongoing debate serves as a reminder that the WNBA is a dynamic and evolving entity, navigating its way through a constantly shifting media landscape.

Data sourced from: