Can an Unforgettable Family Vacation Turn into a 12-Year Nightmare?


Americans Face 12-Year Sentences in Turks and Caicos Over ‘Innocent Mistakes’

Prolonged Ordeal for Four Americans

Bryan Hagerich, a 39-year-old former pro baseball player, was arrested in Turks and Caicos in February after airport security found stray hunting ammunition in his suitcase. Three other American families faced similar predicaments:

  • Tyler Wenrich, 31, a father of a one-year-old, was allowed to return home on bail but awaits sentencing.
  • Ryan Watson, 40, a father of two, remains on the island after being arrested for unknowingly carrying ammo in April.
  • Michael Lee Evans, 72, pleaded guilty to having ammunition on April 24 and will be sentenced on June 18.

Strict Laws, Heavy Penalties

A new mandate in Turks and Caicos imposes severe penalties on tourists caught carrying firearms or ammunition in their bags, including a minimum of 12 years in prison. The U.S. Embassy in the Bahamas warns that “TCI authorities strictly enforce all firearms-and-ammunition-related laws.”

In Hagerich’s Case

Hagerich claims the ammunition was an oversight and was unaware of the strict laws. He fears a 12-year sentence could severely impact his life and family.

Legal Challenges and Exceptional Circumstances

To mitigate the harsh penalties, Hagerich and the other Americans must argue that they had no prior criminal record, had no intention to bring ammunition into the airport, and that a 12-year sentence would be excessive.

Previous Cases and Outcomes

Four Americans detained under the new firearm law were able to avoid prison sentences by paying fines. One individual, however, received an eight-month prison sentence.

Sentencing Dates

Hagerich’s sentencing hearing is scheduled for May 29, while Wenrich and Watson are set to appear in court on June 7. The outcome of their cases will set a precedent for future incidents and the enforcement of the strict firearm laws in Turks and Caicos.

Data sourced from: