Arizona Rancher’s Political Prosecution Alleged, State Weighs Retrial
Costly Trial for Santa Cruz County
As prosecutors debate whether to pursue a second trial against George Alan Kelly, a criminologist claims the state has already spent over million on this “political prosecution.” Dr. Ron Martinelli, working pro bono for Kelly, accused Santa Cruz County Attorney George Silva and Sheriff David Hathaway of biased behavior in the case, involving the death of Gabriel Cuen-Buitimea, a Mexican national shot on January 30, 2023, after Kelly called Border Patrol.
Defense Accusations of Extortion and Ethics Breaches
Martinelli criticized the prosecution’s “extreme confirmation bias” and accused them of employing “lawfare” against Kelly. He claimed the state lacked forensic evidence, presented exculpatory information, and fabricated a motive. Martinelli also highlighted the absence of Silva, Hathaway, and Michael Jette, the contracted prosecutor, from the final day of court proceedings.
Allegations of Cartel Influence and Law Enforcement Incompetence
Martinelli further suggested “definite cartel influence” in the case and accused prosecutors of obstructing the truth. He alleged Hathaway crossed the border to interview a witness who denied being present at the scene. The defense also denounced Hathaway’s testimony about a meeting with a twice-convicted felon linked to weapons trafficking.
Civil Rights Violations and Complaints Against Sheriff
Martinelli asserted that Kelly had his civil rights violated while being held on excessive bond. He threatened to file complaints against Hathaway with multiple law enforcement oversight agencies, including the Department of Justice and the Arizona Commission of Peace Officer Standards and Training.
Frontier Ranchers Under Siege
Martinelli painted a picture of Kelly and other ranchers being vulnerable to armed drug cartel incursions, urging the need for ethical and moral law enforcement systems to protect them.
Public Concerns and Fundraising for Defense
Martinelli expressed concerns about public fear in Santa Cruz County due to cartel influence and questioned the effectiveness of elected officials like Silva and Hathaway in ensuring their safety. Despite using up personal and fundraising resources, the Kellys continue to seek donations and prayers.
Data sourced from: foxnews.com
