School District Withholds Transgender Identity from Parents

2

After facing intense scrutiny, the Murrieta Valley Unified School District has scrapped its “forced outing policy.” This policy would have required staff to disclose students’ gender identity to parents, even if the student objected. The district’s decision followed a determination by the California Department of Education that the policy violated state education codes.

**A Reversal of Course**

The district’s reversal came in a letter sent to staff, students, and families on Friday. The policy, which was approved by the school board in August 2023, has been a source of contention. Opponents argued that it violated students’ privacy, while supporters maintained it was necessary to inform parents.

**Education Code Violations**

The California Department of Education determined that the policy violated Education Code sections 220 and 460. These sections protect students’ confidentiality and the rights of parents to receive accurate information about their children.

**Student Privacy Concerns**

Opponents of the policy cited concerns about student safety, as it could have potentially outed transgender students who were not ready or willing to disclose their identities.

**Parental Involvement**

On the other hand, supporters of the policy argued that parents have a right to know about their child’s gender identity. They contended that this information was essential for making informed decisions about their children’s education and well-being.

**District’s Decision**

After careful consideration, the Murrieta Valley Unified School District ultimately decided to withdraw the controversial policy. The district acknowledged the concerns raised by both sides and expressed its commitment to creating a safe and inclusive learning environment for all students.